Pick Your Poison, by Laura Barbieri, is a light-hearted parody of the ‘country-house murder’ genre, with a cast of stock characters, a high level of arch self-awareness and elements of meta-theatrical comedy. Amongst the stock characters there is a successful authoress of ‘country house murders’ and a mysterious Belgian-accented gentleman with a thick moustache, so we know very well what territory we are in - not to mention the heavily-bewhiskered Judge, the prim and worried secretary, the shifty aristocrat, the drunken doctor with belladonna in his medical bag, the undercover policeman with his notepad and, naturally, the perky French maid.
At the start of the play the maid is setting mousetraps in the drawing room. See what they did there? The country house is on an island, and the bridge to the mainland has collapsed, so no one is getting in or out, and then the power goes down - of course…
A gimmick of the play is that, as the audience file out for the interval, we are asked to vote on the identity of the murderer by placing a coloured disc in a bowl. I am pleased to announce that I chose the correct candidate (although my choice of motive was incorrect). Or was I correct? The last paragraph of this review explains a structural fascination of how this play is constructed, which may be considered a spoiler.
The basic plot is of course generic and unsubtle, rife with comic implausibilities but very neatly constructed. It is really just an excuse to have fun at the expense of all the classic genre tropes. Most importantly it gives the cast a chance to enjoy themselves, and the cast certainly seem to be enjoying themselves, and the audience was clearly enjoying itself.
Emilia Lawonski, as the prim and worried secretary, holds the play together with a delightfully upright performance, culminating in an impressive speech when the inevitable denouement comes around. Jessica Huysing, as the perky French maid (actually grumpy most of the time) stomps amusingly about the stage and conducts an eerie séance at the end of Act One. Laura Mercer, as the shifty aristocrat, plays it as a cross-dressing Hooray Henry, while John Gould, as the drunken doctor, scatters clues about with increasingly sozzled gravitas.
(At this point, might I observe that the first murder that occurs in this play could have been avoided if wine-charms - remember them? - had been around in the 1920s - they weren’t...)
Genevieve Newman, as the successful authoress - did she write the play we are watching? - is engagingly spiky, while Zack Inglis is personable and mysterious as the undercover policeman. Aaron Wilkes is drastically aged and almost unrecognisable as the Judge, with ‘a beard that you could lose a badger in’. (This is the second review in a row of an Old Mill play where I have been able to include that quote, I am pleased to say.) Thomas Kinshela, as Hercul the unexpected Belgian visitor with the large moustache, has great fun with his character and his accent.
Kathleen Del Casale's direction leans bracingly into the comic effects and keeps the ridiculously complicated action moving, which is a real achievement - and there is more to the direction than is visible on a single viewing...
An element of the production which particularly stands out is the lighting and sound design. Virginia Moore-Price's melodramatic lighting plot is almost a character in the play, and is quite dazzling at times (literally): it is used to underscore all the big moments in a comically bombastic way which is frequently also strikingly beautiful. The colour and sound is used like in a ghost-train ride, and there are coloured tableaux which would not be out of place in a Grand Guignol shocker. This may be the first play I have seen where I was looking forward to the lighting cues. The sound keeps up very effectively, and the drawing room set is nicely solid.
There are eight characters in the play, and each one of them has a motive for the deaths that ensue, as is only to be expected. The audience is asked to choose their suspect before the big reveal comes at the end. I was quite pleased with myself for chosing the 'right' suspect, but in fact the play has eight (!) alternative endings, and on any given night any of the characters could be guilty, and the decision is only made in the interval, based on audience response. Choose your own adventure! This is an extraordinary challenge for both playwright and for the cast. Having only seen one outcome I can't say if the other endings are as theatrically effective, but I would be tempted to see the play eight times just to find out...
![]() |
| A poster from a time before modern AI. How refreshing... |
















